Languages · Deep notes
Navajo Diné bizaad nv
The most developed syntax line: Navajo Decoded (Triskellion) builds every clause on one spine, with every form copied from a cited source. ESD has no Navajo stems.
Navajo Decoded: 72 pages linked from its home page
Syntax: what our notes say
- HYPOTHESIS One spine: V→v→T and subject raising from Spec,vP to Spec,TP in every tensed clause. This is Grant’s conjecture, untested (“neither proven nor refuted”), used as the working default since 2026-11-13. VPISH is used to line syntax up with meaning, not as an account of word order. Navajo Decoded derivation Navajo Decoded unified-structure
- OPEN Verb-final order. The cheapest account has T, Neg and C final so nothing else moves; the rival puts T first and moves the rest of the verb phrase above it. Present data do not decide. Navajo Decoded headedness
- HYPOTHESIS The inverse is the object moving above the agent: it changes which phrase is highest, not who does what to whom. Its landing site is OPEN. Navajo Decoded results-on-the-spine Navajo Decoded inverse
- HYPOTHESIS Negation: sentential negation has its head in the final da; doo is adjoined lower; constituent negation with hanii is a different thing. Navajo Decoded results-on-the-spine
- HYPOTHESIS Questions leave the question word where a noun would stand; the question marker is interpreted at the top of the clause (C) and pronounced on a host. Whether the polar particle is a head is OPEN. Navajo Decoded results-on-the-spine Navajo Decoded wh-questions
- NOT UNDERSTOOD The classifier spells a value of v⁰ (H59); this is a description, and its distribution is marked NOT UNDERSTOOD. Navajo Decoded unified-structure Navajo Decoded voice-allomorphy
- HYPOTHESIS Relative and fact clauses: the enclitics =yę́ę / =ígíí are an overt D⁰ taking a whole CP, linked to one participant inside by Agree; nothing moves out (H27b). Navajo Decoded unified-structure Navajo Decoded relatives
- GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant’s headedness view: the word/clause headedness mismatch follows from Merge sites. Whether the sourced prefix orders fit it is OPEN. Navajo Decoded unified-structure Navajo Decoded headedness
Semantics: what our notes say
- HYPOTHESIS Goal: one structure whose c-command relations are the scope relations of the logical form, with every theta role assigned where its argument is merged (VPISH). LFs are neo-Davidsonian. Navajo Decoded unified-structure
- HYPOTHESIS The animacy ranking behind the inverse reads [human], not person (the passive-rank page); plural da- follows the agent across the inverse (number-scope page). Navajo Decoded passive-rank Navajo Decoded number-scope
- HYPOTHESIS Fourth person: an escape from the animacy scale, with five uses (respect, reportative, story, impersonal, wish). Navajo Decoded fourth-person Navajo Decoded fourth-person-uses
- HYPOTHESIS Witherspoon 1977 on yi-/bi- read against Dowty’s proto-agent properties. Navajo Decoded who-acts-on-whom
- OPEN Telicity: no minimal pairs; two narrow claims about enclitic forms are contradicted. Navajo Decoded home
- WITHDRAWN The “roles, not words” thesis was dropped on 2026-11-02 (pages kept as history). Pages that test it, such as the proto-role schema, are kept as history. Light d was withdrawn by Grant on 2026-11-14. Navajo Decoded essays/roles-not-words Navajo Decoded theta-schema Navajo Decoded essays/light-determiners
Notes so far, and gaps
Light n in the noun phrase is OPEN. The first lexical-semantics entry (theme ‘see’) exists only as a data file under /workspace/syntax-trees/lexsem/navajo/ and is not published. ESD lists only the betting class for Navajo (no dedicated four-place stem; periphrastic), and the Group A scout stems are predictions.