Syntax & Semantics Notes

Languages · English · LEXSEM template

smear · English

The ESD entry smear · English, laid out in the LEXSEM-SPEC v0.1 sections. Every value comes from that page and keeps its label. A section the entry does not cover says OPEN. Data file: lexsem/en-lex-smear-en.json (passes validate_lexsem.py).

Identification

FieldStatusValue, cite, note
Citation formOPENno valueSee ESD head. No lexical citation form inferred from a combined headword.
GlossOPENno value
Citation sourceSOURCEDhttps://event-structure-dictionary.pages.dev/verbs/smear-enh1Opened ESD entry. Primary dictionaries cited there were not independently reopened.
RootOPENno value

Event structure

FieldStatusValue, cite, note
TemplateOPENno value

OPEN Pieces: no SPEC tree exists for this entry, so no piece can be tied to a node.

Theta mapping

ArgumentRoleMerge siteStatus and note
esd-role-1none in the role listOPENHYPOTHESIS ours (ESD entry); ESD label Locatum. No merge-site or tree node inferred.
esd-role-2GoalOPENHYPOTHESIS ours (ESD entry); ESD label Goal. No merge-site or tree node inferred.
esd-role-3none in the role listOPENHYPOTHESIS ours (ESD entry); ESD label Location. No merge-site or tree node inferred.
esd-role-4ThemeOPENHYPOTHESIS ours (ESD entry); ESD label Theme. No merge-site or tree node inferred.
What the ESD entry says here (5 quoted passages)
  • ESD TEXT smear · Agent as structural subject + Locatum as structural object + Goal PP (on / over / all over) · Oxford The children had smeared mud on the walls · She smeared the cream liberally on her face · The child had smeared jam all over her face · Merriam-Webster She smeared jam on her toast · Cambridge Mom smeared peanut butter and grape jelly on bagels · The children had smeared peanut butter all over the sofa · Longman Elaine smeared suntan lotion on her shoulders ESD heading: Arguments
  • ESD TEXT smear · Agent as structural subject + Location as structural object + Locatum in a with-PP · Oxford The children had smeared the walls with mud · His face was smeared with blood · Merriam-Webster smeared the paper with glue · The children smeared the window with fingerprints · Cambridge the front of your car is smeared with blood · Longman His face was smeared with mud · NPR smear the bread with butter · Epicurious Smear the bread with some butter ESD heading: Arguments
  • ESD TEXT Location-only · the surface is the structural object, or the subject of a passive or an attributive, and the Locatum is unexpressed · Oxford His glasses were smeared · smeared windows · Longman smeared windows · The rain had dribbled on his glasses and smeared them ESD heading: Arguments
  • ESD TEXT Read the structural object of the on, over, and all over lines as the Locatum, the substance, and the preposition as the surface it goes onto. Read the structural object of smear the walls with mud and of smear the bread with butter as the Location, the surface, and with as the Locatum. The person who smears, when the clause names one, is the structural subject. Dowty’s proto-agent properties sit on that subject when the subject causes the smearing. The proto-patient property of being affected sits on whichever argument is the structural object: the moving substance in frame (a), the surface in frame (b). Which of those two is the object is the alternation. The causative note already uses incremental theme as the proto-patient property that picks the object. This page does not edit that note. ESD heading: Places · who wears which marking
  • ESD TEXT Marking map. On the goal frame, structural object position is the Locatum and the PP is the surface. On the with-frame, structural object position is the surface and the PP is the Locatum. One verb prints both. A location-only clause of the dirty sense leaves the substance out. An intransitive line makes the cosmetic or the paint the subject. Do not read the reputation sense, the microscope slide, or the noun smear as this alternation. ESD heading: Places · who wears which marking

Aspect

FieldStatusValue, cite, note
Lexical classOPENno value
TelicityOPENno valueOPEN by default; needs SOURCED minimal pairs
Mode and aspectOPENno value
What the ESD entry says here (3 quoted passages)
  • ESD TEXT Anderson 1971, Levin 1993 (English Verb Classes and Alternations §2.3.1, the spray/load class), Rappaport and Levin 1988, and Pinker 1989 discuss a reading difference between the two frames of this alternation. When the location is the structural object, as in spray the wall with paint on the spray page, the location is understood as wholly affected. That is the holistic reading. When the Locatum is the structural object and the place is a goal PP, that complete effect on the location is not forced. Levin 1993 states the location in the with-frame as completely affected. The same claim is what those sources make for the class. Smear the walls with mud is that with-frame. Smear mud on the walls is the goal frame. This page records the claim as theirs. It does not add a second syntactic frame for the reading. ESD heading: Holistic reading, and the near verbs
  • ESD TEXT The dictionaries print both frames and do not print a fullness test beside them. Oxford’s with mud and NPR’s with butter do not say that the walls or the bread are fully covered, and they do not say that the covering is partial. Oxford files both frames under one sense, “to spread an oily or soft substance over a surface in a rough or careless way,” and names daub as the synonym. Merriam-Webster splits the glosses. Transitive 1a, the with-frame smeared the paper with glue, is “to overspread with something unctuous, viscous, or adhesive.” Transitive 1b is “to spread over a surface,” and the entry prints no finite clause for that sense. Overspread is the word on the with-frame. The entry does not say that every with-clause forces a whole surface, and it does not apply overspread to the on line jam on her toast. Whether any one printed clause forces the holistic reading is open. ESD heading: Holistic reading, and the near verbs
  • ESD TEXT Levin 2006, “English Object Alternations: A Unified Account,” draft of July 2006, was opened. The putting pair there is Jill sprayed paint on the wall and Jill sprayed the wall with paint. The paper cites Pinker 1989:126–127 for two content-oriented subclasses. One is simultaneous forceful contact and motion of a mass against a surface, and the verbs named there include dab, daub, plaster, smear, smudge, and spread. The other is force imparted to a mass, causing ballistic motion in a specified spatial distribution, and the verbs named there include spray, splash, splatter, sprinkle, and squirt. Pinker 1989 itself was not opened. The subclass lists are as Levin 2006 cites them. What that cut records is manner. Smear is contact of a mass against a surface. Spray is ballistic. The holistic reading those sources discuss for the location-object frame is a claim about the frame, and the draft does not state a separate fullness rule for smear as against spray. ESD heading: Holistic reading, and the near verbs

Selection

OPEN The ESD entry does not state this in a form the template can hold.

Presupposition

OPEN The ESD entry does not state this in a form the template can hold.

Alternations

OPEN The ESD entry does not state this in a form the template can hold.

What the ESD entry says here (4 quoted passages)
  • ESD TEXT A reputation, a microscope slide, a smudge of writing, a result colour, and the noun are not the mud-and-walls pair. Each one states its own arguments. ESD heading: Other senses · their own frames
  • ESD TEXT The dictionaries checked for a reversative verb unsmear are Merriam-Webster and Wiktionary. Merriam-Webster’s page for unsmear returns 404 and no headword. Wiktionary’s page for unsmear returns 404. Wiktionary does enter the adjective unsmeared, “not smeared,” from un- plus smeared. That adjective says the smearing did not take place, or that the thing is not in a smeared state. It is not a verb that undoes a smearing. The OED was not opened. ESD heading: Reversative · unsmear and desmear beside wipe and scrape
  • ESD TEXT Wiktionary enters desmear, from de- plus smear. The sense printed there is to remove debris from a printed circuit board after holes have been drilled in it. That is a technical verb of board manufacture. It is not a clause about butter, mud, or a wall, and the entry prints no surface object and no substance object of the locative pair. Merriam-Webster was not checked for a separate desmear headword beyond the unsmear 404. ESD heading: Reversative · unsmear and desmear beside wipe and scrape
  • ESD TEXT Besmear is attested and is not a reversative. Merriam-Webster: transitive, smear. The example is besmeared the napkin with jelly. The napkin is the object. The jelly is with. The be- prefix does not reverse the frame. It prints the location-object frame of smear. ESD heading: Reversative · unsmear and desmear beside wipe and scrape

LF / denotation

FieldStatusValue, cite, note
Sentence LFOPENno value

OPEN Node denotations: no SPEC tree for this entry, so no node-by-node LF.

Scope

OPEN The ESD entry does not state this in a form the template can hold.

Examples

SOURCED here means printed on the ESD page, which names the dictionary or corpus in its tag. Those works were not reopened for this page.

IdFormSource as taggedStatus
ex-1The children had smeared mud on the walls.Oxford · pattern smear something on/over something · the mud is the structural object · the walls are on · the children are the subjectSOURCED
ex-2The children had smeared the walls with mud.Oxford · pattern smear something with something · the walls are the structural object · the mud is with · same mud and same walls as the on lineSOURCED
ex-3She smeared the cream liberally on her face. · The child had smeared jam all over her face. · She smeared jam on her toast.Oxford extra examples · on and all over · Merriam-Webster examples block · on her toast · the cream, the jam, and the jam are the objectSOURCED
ex-4The children had smeared peanut butter all over the sofa. · Mom smeared peanut butter and grape jelly on bagels for lunch. · Elaine smeared suntan lotion on her shoulders.Cambridge · all over · Cambridge Academic · on · Longman · on · the peanut butter, the jelly, and the lotion are the objectSOURCED
ex-5smeared the paper with glue. · The children smeared the window with fingerprints. · His face was smeared with blood. · the front of your car is smeared with blood.Merriam-Webster transitive 1a · the paper and the window are the object · the glue and the fingerprints are with · Oxford and Cambridge · the face and the car are the location · the blood is withSOURCED
ex-6smear the bread with butter or duck fat. · Smear the bread with some butter. · Halle's face was smeared with butter.NPR, Kitchen Window, 4 Jan. 2011 · the bread is the object · the butter or the duck fat is with · Epicurious, Bread and Butter and Salt · the bread is the object · some butter is with · Longman corpus · the face is the location · the butter is withSOURCED
ex-7His glasses were smeared. · smeared windowsOxford · usually passive · to make something dirty or greasy · the glasses are the subject · the windows are the noun the participle modifies · the substance is unexpressed in both linesSOURCED
ex-8smeared windows · The rain had dribbled on his glasses and smeared them.Longman · dirty · the windows are the noun · the corpus line has them as the object · the rain is the subject of smeared · the substance is unexpressedSOURCED
ex-9Constructed or ruled-out line on ESD. Its form is not copied here (LEXSEM rule 1). Read it on ESD.constructed · Oxford prints the walls as the object of smeared the walls with mud · this line leaves the with-phrase out · an active finite location-only clause with no substance is unprinted in the entries opened here · the printed location-only lines are the glasses and the windowsOPEN
ex-10Wet leaves smeared the pavement.Wiktionary · Hollinghurst, The Line of Beauty, 2004 · the leaves are the subject · the pavement is the object · no with and no on · the substance is the subject and the surface is the objectSOURCED
ex-11Jam was smeared all over his face. · Butter was smeared all over the counter.Oxford · smudge sense, be smeared + adv./prep. · the jam is the passive subject · all over his face stays · Merriam-Webster examples · the butter is the passive subject · all over the counter staysSOURCED
ex-12Her mascara smeared when she cried. · her makeup had smeared. · The paint is still wet — don't touch it or it will smear.Merriam-Webster examples · the mascara is the subject · no surface object · Longman corpus · the makeup is the subject · Wiktionary · intransitive, the paint is the subject of will smearSOURCED
ex-13Constructed or ruled-out line on ESD. Its form is not copied here (LEXSEM rule 1). Read it on ESD.constructed · Merriam-Webster prints She smeared jam on her toast · this line leaves the on-phrase out · a finite locatum-only clause with no goal is unprinted in the entries opened here · Merriam-Webster transitive 1b, to spread over a surface, prints no finite clauseOPEN
ex-14Constructed or ruled-out line on ESD. Its form is not copied here (LEXSEM rule 1). Read it on ESD.constructed · the bread and the butter are NPR smear the bread with butter and Epicurious Smear the bread with some butter · on is Oxford mud on the walls and Merriam-Webster jam on her toast · no opened dictionary prints butter as the object of on the bread · the Google Books Ngram string smear butter on is non-zero and is not a quoted sentenceOPEN
ex-15Smear the bread with butter.NPR · smear the bread with butter or duck fat · Epicurious drops or duck fat and prints some · the infinitive and the imperative are the sources’SOURCED
ex-16Constructed or ruled-out line on ESD. Its form is not copied here (LEXSEM rule 1). Read it on ESD.constructed · onto is unprinted in Oxford, Cambridge, Longman, Merriam-Webster, and Wiktionary as opened · the printed goal prepositions of the finite lines are on, over, and all overOPEN
ex-17Constructed or ruled-out line on ESD. Its form is not copied here (LEXSEM rule 1). Read it on ESD.constructed · with of the surface · unprinted · the surface of the locatum-object frame is on, over, or all overOPEN
ex-18Constructed or ruled-out line on ESD. Its form is not copied here (LEXSEM rule 1). Read it on ESD.constructed · onto of the substance when the bread is the object · unprinted · the substance beside a surface object is withOPEN
ex-19His face was smeared with blood. · the front of your car is smeared with blood. · Halle's face was smeared with butter.Oxford · Cambridge · Longman corpus · the face and the car are the location · with staysSOURCED
ex-20Jam was smeared all over his face. · Butter was smeared all over the counter.Oxford · Merriam-Webster · the jam and the butter are the Locatum · all over stays · the surface is not the subjectSOURCED
ex-21He daubed some cologne on his neck. · Daub the potatoes with a little butter. · Various political slogans had been daubed on the walls.Merriam-Webster · daub · locatum object and on, or location object and with · transitive 1 is “to cover or coat with soft adhesive matter : plaster” · transitive 3b is “to apply (something, such as paint) crudely” · a little butter is the printed quantity · the example does not say the potatoes are wholly coveredSOURCED
ex-22Dab or spray the scent on your … wrist. · dabbing fresh paint on the surfaceMerriam-Webster · dab · “to apply lightly or irregularly : daub” · the scent and the paint are the object · the wrist and the surface are on · the noun sense is “a small amount” · the entry does not gloss this verb as overspreadSOURCED
ex-23They plastered the walls with posters. · Someone had plastered a political poster on the wall. · We plastered and sanded the walls before painting them.Merriam-Webster · plaster · location object and with, or the poster as object and on · transitive 1 is “to overlay or cover with plaster : coat” · sense 6 is “to affix to or place on especially conspicuously or in quantity” · the walls-only line leaves the substance outSOURCED
ex-24Coat the chicken with flour. · My shoes are coated with mud. · Rock dust coated his hair.Merriam-Webster · coat · the chicken and the shoes are the location · the flour and the mud are with · the dust is the subject and the hair is the object · transitive senses are “to cover with a coat” and “to cover or spread with a finishing, protecting, or enclosing layer” · a finite coat flour on the chicken is unprinted in that entrySOURCED
ex-25The gardener covered the soil with mulch. · Cover the seedbed with straw. · Snow covered the hills.Merriam-Webster · cover · the soil and the seedbed are the object · the mulch and the straw are with · the snow is the subject and the hills are the object · a finite cover mulch on the soil is unprinted in that entrySOURCED
ex-26I need to paint the bookcase. · We're going to paint the room yellow. · paint the wound with iodine. · The classroom wall was painted with clouds and rainbows.Merriam-Webster · paint · the bookcase, the room, the wound, and the wall are the object · yellow is the result adjective · the iodine is with · the clouds and rainbows are with and are the image, not a mass of paint · a finite paint paint on the wall is unprinted in that entry · Levin 2006 files paint with the image-impression verbs, not in the contact list that includes smearSOURCED
ex-27The story was an attempt to smear the party leader.Oxford · to damage somebody’s reputation by saying unpleasant things that are not true · the story is the subject · the party leader is the object · no with and no onSOURCED
ex-28She decided to sue for libel after the newspaper smeared her private life. · He was smeared in the newspapers.Cambridge · the private life is the object · the newspapers are in, which is the place of publication and not the wall of the mud frame · Academic · the person is the passive subjectSOURCED
ex-29an attempt to smear the party leadershipLongman · the leadership is the object · the definition is an untrue story about someone importantSOURCED
ex-30Young researchers take a drop of blood, smear it on a slide, stain it and check it under the microscope.Longman corpus · it is the drop of blood · the slide is on · the same object choice as mud on the walls · the purpose in the line is the preparation, which is Merriam-Webster’s medical sense “to prepare as a smear for microscopic examination”SOURCED
ex-31The last few words of the letter were smeared. · Several words were smeared.Oxford · to rub writing so that it is no longer clear · the words are the subject · Longman · the words are the subject · no surface PP in these linesSOURCED
ex-32small wooden dolls smeared red as though with blood · smeared a bluish green · smeared his forehead pinkWiktionary quotations · Burton · Williams · Seth · the dolls, the fences in the Williams line, and the forehead are the location · the colour is the result · with blood is inside as thoughSOURCED
ex-33besmeared the napkin with jellyMerriam-Webster · besmear · the napkin is the object · the jelly is with · the verb means smear · not a reversativeSOURCED
ex-34wipe the spots off the glass · Would you wipe the dishes? · Scrape the paint from the wood.Merriam-Webster · wipe removes the spots or cleans the dishes · scrape removes the paint · the glass and the wood are the source · the dishes are the surface and the substance is unexpressedSOURCED
ex-35unsmearedWiktionary · adjective · “not smeared” · not a finite verb unsmearSOURCED
ex-36Constructed or ruled-out line on ESD. Its form is not copied here (LEXSEM rule 1). Read it on ESD.constructed · no verb unsmear in Merriam-Webster or Wiktionary as opened · the attested un- form is the adjective unsmeared · desmear on Wiktionary is the circuit-board verb and is not this clauseOPEN

Open questions

  1. Smear butter on the bread as one clause. Constructed. NPR and Epicurious print smear the bread with butter. Oxford prints mud on the walls. Merriam-Webster prints jam on her toast. The Google Books Ngram string smear butter on is non-zero and is not a quoted sentence.
  2. Onto. Unprinted in the entries opened here. On, over, and all over are printed. Oxford’s collocation list names across. Whether those are one Goal slot is open. Smear butter onto the bread is constructed.
  3. Whether with is a complement or an adjunct. Open. The phrase is present when the location-object lines name the substance. The glasses and the windows omit it.
  4. The holistic reading on a particular printed clause. Open. Anderson 1971, Levin 1993 §2.3.1, Rappaport and Levin 1988, and Pinker 1989 discuss it for the alternation. Merriam-Webster glosses the with-frame as overspread. Oxford does not. Levin 2006 says the on-frame of smear need not cover the face. The dictionaries do not print a fullness test. A difference between the with-frame of smear and the with-frame of spray is not what those sources state. The manner cut they do state is contact against ballistic motion.
  5. Smear the walls with no substance, and smear the jam with no goal. Constructed. The printed location-only lines are the glasses and the windows. The printed locatum lines keep on, over, or all over.
  6. A verb unsmear. No headword in Merriam-Webster or Wiktionary as opened. Wiktionary records the adjective unsmeared. The Google Books string unsmear has a relative frequency and no sentence is quoted from it. The OED was not opened.
  7. Desmear. Wiktionary’s sense is debris on a drilled circuit board. It is not filed here as the inverse of smear the walls with mud.
  8. The algebraic paragraph. Analogy and hypothesis only. Partial maps, a partial inverse, and non-commutativity of smear with wipe are not dictionary facts.
  9. 塗る. Wiktionary glosses this English verb with 塗る and 塗り付ける. The alternation name 壁塗り構文 is on the Japanese spray page. 塗る is not a page on this site.