Syntax & Semantics Notes

Languages · English · Worked examples

Pat paid Chris twenty dollars.

OPEN Constructed line on ESD (ESD’s own example, not a sourced attestation; no judgment added): ESD constructed line (frame ledger)

Its verb on ESD: ESD entry: pay_GIVE · ESD sense card: pay_GIVE · template of the ESD entry

Fine difference: pay_GIVE vs pay_BILL

HYPOTHESIS The tree and the LF are our analysis, drawn with the shared SPEC renderer from trees/ex/cx-en-pay-give-1.json; the LEXSEM block is lexsem-ex/en-lex-cx-en-pay-give-1.json and passes validate_lexsem.py. Working defaults: VPISH; V→v→T and the subject raising to Spec,TP (Grant’s untested conjecture); no light d; no light n. Every attachment our notes do not cover is marked OPEN.

Identification

FieldStatusValue, cite, note
Citation formOPENno value
GlossOPENno valueESD sense: pay-give
Citation sourceSOURCEDhttps://event-structure-dictionary.pages.dev/verbs/pay-giveentry pageopened ESD entry; the primary work is cited there
RootOPENno value

Event structure

FieldStatusValue, cite, note
TemplateHYPOTHESIS[x0 v [√pay_GIVE …]]ours; drawn in the linked tree. The predicate name in the LF is a label of the ESD entry/sense, not a claim that all listed translations have identical meanings.

Theta mapping

ArgumentRoleMerge siteStatus and note
x0none in the role listSpec,vPHYPOTHESIS ours; external argument; role label Payer (ESD place name, outside the template role list)
x2none in the role listVP-complementHYPOTHESIS ours; complement of V⁰; role label Amount (ESD place name, outside the template role list)
x1RecipientSpec,ApplP-lowHYPOTHESIS ours; applied argument; role label Recipient

Aspect

FieldStatusValue, cite, note
Lexical classOPENno value
TelicityOPENno valueOPEN by default; needs SOURCED minimal pairs
Mode and aspectOPENno value

Selection

OPEN The ESD entry does not state this in a form the template can hold.

Presupposition

OPEN The ESD entry does not state this in a form the template can hold.

Alternations

OPEN The ESD entry does not state this in a form the template can hold.

LF / denotation

Pat paid Chris twenty dollars. (pay_GIVE), HYPOTHESISConstructed line on ESD (no speaker judgment added): “Pat paid Chris twenty dollars.”. Our analysis (HYPOTHESIS): VPISH, the subject first merged in Spec,vP; V→v→T and the subject raising to Spec,TP (Grant’s conjecture, untested). No light d; no light n. Attachments, headedness, morphological segmentation and the derivation of surface word order not established in our notes are OPEN. The tree is an argument-structure hypothesis, not a complete surface parse. Non-core adverbs and clause material not drawn are left unanalyzed. No English role name on a zxx leaf is a newly proposed form. LF: ∃e[pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2) ∧ Recipient(e,x1) ∧ Payer(e,x0)] Full structure in the list below the figure.TPDPPatT′T⁰vPDPPatv′v⁰ApplPDPChrisAppl′Appl⁰hypothesis◇VPV′V⁰paidDPtwenty dollarshead-movehead-moveMove
(1) Pat paid Chris twenty dollars. (pay_GIVE), HYPOTHESIS Hypothesis ESD pay-give · ESD constructed line (frame ledger)
Bracket notation (copy)

[TP [DP Pat] [T′ T⁰ [vP ⟨DP⟩ [v′ v⁰ [ApplP [DP Chris] [Appl′ Appl⁰ [VP [V′ [V⁰ paid] [DP twenty dollars]]]]]]]]]

Structure as a list
  • TP (id TP)
    • DP (id S-high; landing site of Move from subject): Pat
    • T′ (id Tbar)
      • T⁰ (head; id T)
      • vP (id vP)
        • DP (id subject; struck copy; moved to S-high): Pat
        • v′ (id vbar)
          • v⁰ (head; id v; head-moves to T)
          • ApplP (id ApplP)
            • DP (id arg1): Chris
            • Appl′ (id Applbar)
              • Appl⁰ (head; id Appl; ◇ hypothesis)
              • VP (id VP)
                • V′ (id Vbar)
                  • V⁰ (head; id V; head-moves to v): paid
                  • DP (id arg2): twenty dollars
Node ids and their LF rows
FieldStatusValue, cite, note
Sentence LFHYPOTHESIS∃e[pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2) ∧ Recipient(e,x1) ∧ Payer(e,x0)]ours; equals the tree’s LF line
Tree nodeLabelTypeDenotationRuleStatus and note
arg1DPex1lexicalHYPOTHESIS ours; x1 is the referent of “Chris”
arg2DPex2lexicalHYPOTHESIS ours; x2 is the referent of “twenty dollars”
VV⁰<e,<v,t>>λy1.λe. pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,y1)lexicalHYPOTHESIS ours; the root introduces its internal roles (VPISH: each role where its argument merges)
VbarV′<v,t>λe. pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2)FAHYPOTHESIS ours
VPVP<v,t>λe. pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2)OPENHYPOTHESIS ours; non-branching node, passes up ⟦V′⟧
ApplAppl⁰<e,<v,t>>λx.λe. Recipient(e,x)lexicalHYPOTHESIS ours; a low applicative layer. It is composed here by Event Identification, the simpler event-relating option; which is right is OPEN.
ApplbarAppl′<e,<v,t>>λx.λe. pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2) ∧ Recipient(e,x)EIHYPOTHESIS ours
ApplPApplP<v,t>λe. pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2) ∧ Recipient(e,x1)FAHYPOTHESIS ours
subjectDPex0lexicalHYPOTHESIS ours; x0 is the referent of “Pat”
vv⁰<e,<v,t>>λx.λe. Payer(e,x)lexicalHYPOTHESIS ours; v⁰ introduces the external argument (VPISH working default)
vbarv′<e,<v,t>>λx.λe. pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2) ∧ Recipient(e,x1) ∧ Payer(e,x)EIHYPOTHESIS ours
vPvP<v,t>λe. pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2) ∧ Recipient(e,x1) ∧ Payer(e,x0)FAHYPOTHESIS ours
TT⁰<<v,t>,t>λP. ∃e P(e)∃-closureHYPOTHESIS ours; tense abstracted away
TbarT′t∃e[pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2) ∧ Recipient(e,x1) ∧ Payer(e,x0)]FAHYPOTHESIS ours
S-highDPOPENHYPOTHESIS ours: the subject is interpreted at its lower copy, so the raised copy contributes nothing here
TPTPt∃e[pay_GIVE(e) ∧ Amount(e,x2) ∧ Recipient(e,x1) ∧ Payer(e,x0)]OPENHYPOTHESIS ours; = ⟦T′⟧ (S-high vacuous)

Scope

OPEN The ESD entry does not state this in a form the template can hold.

Examples

SOURCED here means printed on the ESD page, which names the dictionary or corpus in its tag. Those works were not reopened for this page.

IdFormSource as taggedStatus
ex-1Pat paid Chris twenty dollars. (constructed line on ESD; form value left null, LEXSEM rule 1)OPEN

Open questions

  1. Attachments, headedness, morphological segmentation and the derivation of surface word order not established in our notes are OPEN. The tree is an argument-structure hypothesis, not a complete surface parse. Non-core adverbs and clause material not drawn are left unanalyzed. No English role name on a zxx leaf is a newly proposed form.